A growing chorus of voices in business circles believes that many newly minted professionals are arriving on the job without the level of workplace finesse that seasoned colleagues expect. Surveys suggest that a large majority of hiring managers see gaps in areas like handling feedback, communicating clearly, resolving conflicts, and generally knowing when to power down their phones. These perceived shortcomings may not be universal, but they’re substantial enough to spark conversations about whether today’s work culture—and the expectations that define it—require not just a tweak, but a more significant overhaul.
At the heart of the debate is a generational shift. Younger employees, many of whom place a premium on authenticity, want to show up at work with their entire, unfiltered selves. Meanwhile, traditional office norms still prize professionalism, structured communication, and deference to hierarchy. While it’s tempting to frame this as a clash between the “free-spirited” and the “old guard,” it’s more constructive to see it as the growing pains of a professional landscape that continues to evolve in real time.
Why the disconnect?
Part of the issue is undoubtedly rooted in the pandemic’s disruption. Many new graduates saw their formative professional years swallowed by lockdowns or remote learning, where the everyday give-and-take of a physical office was replaced by video calls, instant messages, and digital coursework. Without regular exposure to seasoned mentors in person, they missed out on the unspoken lessons of professional etiquette: how to receive critical feedback without bristling, how to temper personal conversation topics in group settings, or when that quick check of social media can come across as inattentive.
Another reason is the overall shift toward casual culture in workplaces. Casual dress codes and remote-friendly policies have blurred the lines between personal and professional spaces. People who only a few years ago would have steeled themselves into crisp business attire now feel more relaxed—maybe a little too relaxed, some critics argue.
To be clear, a handful of managers highlight relatively straightforward concerns: phone addiction, an inability to handle constructive criticism, and a penchant for bringing deeply personal or controversial topics into the office. Others observe a perceived lack of polish, from repeated use of filler words to blunt, overly direct emails announcing, “I’m going on leave, bye!”—all of which can be off-putting in organizations that still value hierarchical protocols.
A call for more than a quick fix
Some observers claim these issues can be resolved by a few training sessions or quick etiquette workshops. But the real conversation runs deeper. Critics of the status quo argue that the very concept of “professionalism” must be reimagined so that younger workers can be themselves without jeopardizing their reputations or careers. On the flip side, more traditional voices maintain that there’s no shortcut around the fundamentals: courtesy, responsibility, and respect for the team’s time and energy.
The truth likely lies between these two positions. On one hand, there is a reason professional expectations exist: they foster trust, instill discipline, and ensure that teams function smoothly. “Nothing comes for free” is not just an empty cliché; it’s a reminder that professional respect has to be earned through consistent reliability, thoughtful communication, and awareness of one’s environment. No one wants to do business with a colleague who casually shrugs off deadlines or who never quite acknowledges others’ needs.
Also read: Gen Z Social Media Trends
On the other hand, a younger generation’s emphasis on authenticity and well-being shouldn’t be dismissed. People work best when they feel safe to be themselves. A more flexible work culture can breed creativity, camaraderie, and fresh perspectives—assets any savvy business leader should treasure. Perhaps the problem isn’t that Gen Z has to be molded into a decades-old template, but that the whole system needs updating to accommodate both courtesy and candor.
Finding middle ground
Several businesses have started offering etiquette training or structured onboarding programs aimed at closing these divides. Such programs don’t exist to stifle individuality; in many cases, they give new hires clarity on what an organization counts as respectful conduct. Clear guidelines reduce guesswork and help employees feel confident about sharing their ideas, requesting leave, or simply collaborating across generations.
But training alone can’t solve the tension. Managers, especially those steeped in older ways, may need to accept some informality as a welcome sign that their teams are comfortable being open. Younger employees, for their part, must recognize the implicit contract of the workplace: when you show respect and competence, you get trust and room to grow.
In practical terms, that might mean editing out a few “likes” and “totallys” when speaking to senior leaders, or learning the art of requesting feedback with composure. It might also mean older colleagues easing the reins a bit, recognizing that while a quick “I’m out tomorrow, thanks!” email might sound abrupt, it could also signal a new era of candid, low-drama communication.
Room for hope—and action
Whether one sees this as a passing phase or an overdue revolution in office culture, it’s clear that each generation has something to learn. The balance between authenticity and professionalism is delicate and contextual—it always has been. What’s new is the intense speed at which workplaces are evolving, compressed further by social media norms, remote work, and wider societal change.
Those who adapt—both managers who learn to trust fresh voices and newcomers who appreciate the deeper reasons behind professional protocols—will find themselves better positioned in a transforming economy. Instead of a clash of the ages, workplaces can aspire to a genuine partnership, where courtesy meets new ideas and formality coexists with creative disruption. The bottom line? There’s more at stake than just an updated etiquette guide. It might be time for a broader cultural reset, one that respects hard-earned lessons of the past while encouraging the vitality and authenticity of the next generation.